India's Golden Conundrum

Indian’s love for gold is spiritual where it is revered as God’s currency. It is only astronomically higher prices which can resist them to buy it. Falling prices are just what India wanted at a time when festival and wedding season is ensuing.

The king of metal Gold is again going south. It touched a 14-month low on September 20, 2014. Such a scenario induces people away from gold to flock into financial instruments. The metal will no longer lure Indians is what analysts believe but India’s thirst for gold will take eternity to be quenched.

Falling gold prices might lead people in other countries to ditch the yellow metal but Indian’s love for gold is spiritual where it is revered as God’s currency and people feel proud of owning it. It is only astronomically higher prices which can resist them to buy it. Gold demand slumped magically when import duty was hiked to 10% in order to control current account deficit. Now that prices are falling, it will be seen as an opportunity to purchase it on low in the hope of price-rise. Long-term return outlook of a common investor in India is always bullish on gold.

Current account deficit (CAD) narrowed sharply to $7.8 billion (1.7 per cent of gross domestic product) in the Apr-Jun quarter of FY 2014-15 from $21.8 billion (4.8 per cent of GDP) in the year ago period. The fall was strongly led by slowdown in gold imports which halved to $7 billion in the April-June quarter from $16.5 billion in the same quarter a year ago. However, the gold imports in the preceding quarter i.e. the Jan-Mar quarter of FY 2013-14 amounted to US$ 5.3 billion. 

To compare the two data, gold imports actually risen on quarterly basis. The reason is because RBI had eased some gold-import restrictions in the month of May which instantly drove the people to invest in gold. This uptick in demand is reflected in the gold import data of Apr-Jun 2014.

It is true that the gold investment at this juncture does not seem viable. Gold futures are trading lower. Improving global economy does not bode well for the metal, to boot. Stronger dollar is also contributing to Gold’s southward journey as gold is used as a hedge against movement in the US dollar, which means its prices will move inversely to change in value of dollar. Indian gold prices move in tandem with global prices depending on rupee’s value against dollar. Since India imports the yellow metal, a weaker rupee cushions a fall in gold price while a stronger local unit makes the metal cheaper. Given improving economic conditions, rupee may not depreciate much against dollar.

That said, why to invest in a declining metal when stock markets are doing well and lower inflation is making returns on savings schemes positive? The answer lies in a trend seen last year. Gold prices had fallen dramatically in Apr-Jun quarter of 2013. Questions were raised if it safe to invest in this yellow metal but coming true to the conscience of Indians, gold hit a record high of Rs.35,074 per 10 grams in August 2013. Hence, it is no hyperbole that Gold is the safest haven amongst all.

With the ensuing festival and wedding season, India’s gold buying binge is likely to be bumper. Low prices at this time are just what India wanted. Irrationally higher import duty had enforced them to stay away from the metal for long but now is the opportunity to buy it on dips. Thus, India’s golden problem is not yet resolved and it is too early to claim that the country’s CAD is normalized. India’s lure for gold can be suppressed but cannot be died in any case. 

Taper proof

Thanks to RBI and FM, the specter of imminent fed taper couldn’t haunt markets as it did back in May. 

In what served as a nightmare for Indian economy back in May, when turned real was treated as a business as usual. The much discussed and feared US dollar tapering by Federal Reserve, first announcement of which shook the cores of rupee is finally set to begin from New Year.  Dollar inflows are to be narrowed down in the markets but thanks to the improved level of Current Account Deficit, the difference between outflow and inflow of the foreign exchange, rupee wouldn’t lose its stand against dollar. 

US Federal Reserve Chief Ben Bernanke on Thursday announced to cut down on its monthly dollar minting program by $10bn, bringing it to $75bn dollar. Fed, with an effort to spur growth, had been pumping in cheap money to the tune of $85bn in its economy on monthly basis which in turn also benefitted emerging market economies wherein US investors parked that cheaply acquired money for better returns. India was one of the beneficiaries of this program. However, Fed Chief announced to taper off liquidating dollars in May 2013. Mere his words were enough to scare the investors though final decision was yet to be taken. Foreign Institutional Investment (FIIs) began flocking out depreciating rupee’s value against dollar, which touched its all time low in August at Rs. 68.85 per dollar. It is only after drastic measures taken by Reserve Bank of India and Finance Ministry to attract dollars and cut down on imports that rupee could be strengthened.

In this background, it is surprising that panic-stricken response shown by markets back then didn’t come to pass now, now when taper is certain and just round the corner. To compare the current scenario from May, India is better placed at all fronts. First, the time and pace of taper was uncertain then which is not only clear but bearable at $10bn reduction a month. Secondly, India’s foreign reserve and CAD have improved a lot. The unprecedented surge in gold imports of earlier times could be controlled including few other non essential and expensive imports. CAD narrowed sharply to $5.2 billion, or 1.2 per cent of GDP, in the July-September quarter of 2013-14 which hovered around 4-5% in the previous quarters. In addition, RBI’s move taken in Sep 2013 to ease it for banks to run Foreign Currency Non-residents (banks) deposit scheme has also played out well. Under FCNR (B) scheme NRIs do not face currency risk; the currency risk is borne by banks. RBI had helped banks reduce this risk so that they attract more of NRIs to make use of this scheme and don’t stay away from offering it in the tight domestic currency scenario. 

These measures apart from turnaround in exports have made Indian economy resilient enough to face imminent outflows of dollars. Initially rupee might lose traction against dollar but that wouldn’t be severe and wouldn’t sustain for long. Considering US economy is back on growth trajectory, fed taper can instead be positive for India in a sense that demand boost in US will drive export growth of Indian export enterprises having business in US. That is double dose good news for them as lately they are already reaping benefits of surge in exports.

The specter of Fed Reserve taper is no more there to haunt. India’s external front is under control for now. It is time that all efforts are put to reduce notoriously high inflation, the pivot of economic growth cycle and thus boost industrial production bringing jobs and growth in the country.

Seeing the Silver-linings

India’s export business is bleak and currency depreciation is a tried and tested formula to boost it, rupee’s fall CAN be translated into export-growth, CAN turn out to be a positive for Indian economy. 

And the rupee goes past 66 per dollar! An all-time low! Its swinging motion in the range of 61-66 per dollar has become a cause of concern for Finance Ministry and Reserve Bank of India. Though their panic-stricken remedies adopted to cure rupee’s free-fall do suggest that economy might go down into dumps if currency doesn’t stabilize but considering that India’s export business is bleak and currency depreciation is a tried and tested formula to boost it, rupee’s fall CAN be translated into export-growth, CAN turn out to be a positive for Indian economy.

Scrambling to tame burgeoning CAD and thus halt rupee’s slide, Chidambaram hiked import duty on gold, silver and platinum to 10% and also hinted to raise duties on non-essential luxury items such as air-conditioners, refrigerators and expensive watches. It has also asked state-run financial institutions to raise funds abroad through quasi-sovereign bonds, and liberalized rules on overseas commercial borrowing so that more dollars can be brought in India. Not only FM, but monetary policy supremo RBI is also up with its efforts through its liquidity tightening measures. It restricted banks’ easy access to money so that bank-financing for speculators who create pseudo dollar-demand in currency market, can be curbed. Apart from these, RBI also put drastic capital controls on Indian residents and companies to stem the dollar outflow. Now only $75000 can be remitted by resident-individuals which is a steep fall from earlier limit of $200,000. Also, no Indian company can invest more than 100% of its net worth in foreign countries which could earlier invest 400% of their net worth.

Unfortunately nothing translated into rupee’s stability and it went beyond 66 per dollar. What was supposed to work for rupee didn’t help it, rather backfired hitting the economy with collateral damage. On one hand increased lending rates due to liquidity tightening is eating on the already dilapidated growth, on the other recent capital and import controls have fuelled the panic arose out of rupee’s fall. Not only foreign but even Indian investors are now losing faith from Indian economy.

Now that much has been tried to stem rupee, it is time that it is left to take its own course. Rupee’s fall is just a phase of wheeling vicious cycle which by itself would come down to a stable level. Indian credit rating agency CRISIL has in fact predicted that rupee will stabilize at rs. 60/dollar by March 14.

It is time RBI and Govt. accept that they are short of arsenal to protect rupee. They must instead look for ways to make the best use of rupee depreciation. Japan and South Korea in sixties and China in nineties had deliberately weakened their currency in planned manner to boost export, which actually paid them well. In fact, rupee’s fall has begun making positive impact on India’s export-business.  Exports rose by 11.64% in July. Also, rupee’s value against dollar is at a level which gives it competitive advantage in exports as compared to currencies of other countries including China. The most important point to consider is that export-boom, if it at all it happens, can eventually ease pressure on rupee through an increased flow of dollars.

Hence it is time that cheaper rupee is converted into export-drive. It would not only perk up India’s internal sustenance but also help restore investor-confidence in Indian economy.

Double Trouble

To maintain forex stability at the time of QE withdrawal and maturation of external debt is going to be a tough call for Government.

Reserve Bank of India recently reported that India’s external debt i.e. loans borrowed from foreign lenders has reached to as much as 21.2% of the GDP ($390bn) as of March end. The news has come in the backdrop of depreciating rupee which has already crossed the psychological 60 due to dearth of dollars in the country and might even go up given the series of internal and external structural challenges. Though the recent Current Account Deficit data standing at 3.6% of GDP for Jan-Mar quarter as compared to 6.7% of the previous quarter has rekindled the hope of strengthening rupee but rising external debt and their soon-to-come maturation period certainly spills water on this hope as repayment of these debts has to be made in dollars, thus causing upward pressure on rupee.

External debt mainly consists of External Commercial Borrowings (ECBs), NRI deposits and short-term credit. Worryingly, the share of short-term debt stands at 44.2% of the total debt which has to be repaid in the next one year. By the same time American Federal Reserve will also be tapering off quantitative easing (QE) as announced by Fed Chief Ben Bernanke few days ago. During American recession, under its QE policy, Fed was pumping $85 bn dollars in the economy on monthly basis which is going to be rolled back as American economy is back on the recovery path. India being the biggest beneficiary of American QE will now turn out to be the biggest loser as its major source of capital inflows i.e. Foreign Institutional Investment (FII) is likely to be ended by mid 2014. In fact, impact of this announcement is already palpable given the free fall of rupee for the past few weeks as many foreign investors have been selling out their bonds and stocks from Indian market. To maintain forex stability at the time of QE withdrawal and maturation of external debt is going to be a tough call for Government.

While Govt. has no say in decreasing or increasing FIIs inflow but it must try to control external borrowings. Cheaper foreign money prompts India Inc to borrow funds from other countries while lending rates in India are skyrocketing with no sign of coming down due to high inflation. Although external borrowings has a positive side too as it stimulates dollar inflow in the economy but relying on ECBs, short-term credit or NRI deposits etc. for forex stability is dangerous due to its being highly volatile. Now that the value of rupee against dollar has been sharply falling, it might lead Indian companies to pay their foreign debts sooner than later as their repayment amount in dollar terms is piling up due to exchange rate vulnerability towards rupee. Their dollar-demand for repayment will further cause rupee to weaken against dollar. Considering this, RBI along with Finance Ministry would better adopt measures to maintain internal stability rather than becoming victim to external sector vulnerability. Yet RBI recently eased ECB norms in order to attract dollar-inflows. It can be temporarily acceptable for short-term boost to rupee but certainly not a viable option given the risk factor associated with it.

India’s heavy dependence on imports is the root cause of its weak currency which is also the bedrock of rising inflation i.e. the prime cause of economic slowdown. India stands at fifth position among countries having largest coal reserves yet it is one of the biggest importer of coal due to poor coal-mining in the country. Also more than 80% of India’s oil demand is met via imports. It is also the biggest importer of gold which had raised India’s CAD to unprecedented level. However, gold import could be curbed by bumping up import duty on the same but it is difficult to divert people’s attention from this yellow metal for its being a sure hedge against inflation. Stringent measures have to be taken by Finance Ministry and RBI to mitigate India’s heavy reliance on imports as direct and indirect impact of rising commodity prices and services chargers not only surge inflation but also raise production cost thus making export products costlier leading India to lose in competitive export market from other countries offering cheaper products.

India is stuck in a gruesome vicious cycle. Solution of one problem works as the catalyst for another. In this backdrop, finding a balanced solution and thus shifting to virtuous cycle is a herculean task for Government. Tough times for Indian economy and the lesson must be learnt that heavy dependence on precarious global economy while being in throes of weak domestic economy is not prudent. A robust, domestically sustained economy can only bear the brunt of sudden emergence of internal and external turbulence.

Glittery Gold Jittery Government

Instead of cynically hiking import duty, Govt. would do well if it paves way for either virtual trading of gold or it should launch gold-indexed bonds instead of inflation indexed bonds.

Unmindful of its earlier failed efforts of controlling gold-import and discouraging its demand, Govt. once again resorted to the same trick by ratcheting up gold import duty to 8% from 6% (fourth hike within two years) disregarding the speculative undertone it might generate. Reserve Bank of India (RBI), in the vein of Govt., levied more stringent restrictions on banks to import gold and provide loans to public. Given the ballooning Current Account Deficit and badly depreciating rupee against dollar, curbing gold purchase seems the only viable step to Govt. to tame the imbalance of payment but it is highly unlikely if it would discourage the people to invest in gold as its being the safe and lucrative haven is a widely popular notion in the country challenging which is a tough nut to crack.

The unprecedented fall in gold prices in the month of April somewhat provided sense of relief to Government but unfortunately the impact of price-fall substantially got counterbalanced by surge in demand due to wedding and festival season in the country with gold imports touching 162 tonnes in May. Rising gold imports also pushed the trade deficit to $17.7 billion in April. Further trouble befell with the consistent depreciation of rupee which has now surpassed 57 against dollar bricking the prospect of even more widening CAD leading to even higher inflation which is already at an intolerant level.

It is in this backdrop that the Govt. has hiked gold import duty and RBI asked banks and nominated agencies to not import gold on a consignment basis for domestic use. Also, RBI disallowed import of gold on credit and advised banks to dissuade people from parking their savings in this glittery metal. Co-operative banks have been told to only lend against gold ornaments, gold jewellery and gold coins weighing up to 50 grams, amount of which must be within the Board approved limit. Though these measures might serve the purpose of Govt. in the shorter term but considering the fact that steps of similar kind have already been exercised earlier for no avail, it would not provide a medium term solution let alone long-term. The vicious cycle of yawning CAD, rising inflation, falling rupee and sputtering growth is the result of structural deficiencies but Govt. is hell-bent to put onus on Indian’s lure of Gold and fuel subsidies.

Considering the dearth of inflation-hedged investment options, Govt. has though launched the first tranche of Inflation Indexed Bonds but the fact that its coupon rate and principal amount are indexed against Wholesale Price Inflation (WPI) not Consumer Price Inflation (CPI), returns on these bonds would not be much profitable as its latter not former which directly affects the consumers. On the other hand Gold, despite its price-fall provides favourable return against rising inflation. Also, the ease of purchase, as against IIBs for which one has to go through the tedious system of opening bank accounts, filling up litany of forms, understanding complex formula etc, makes it handy and an obvious choice for investors over any other financial instruments.

Gold-frenzy is a global phenomenon. Only difference is that Government worldwide has channelled this frenzy into paper-based trading of Gold. Given this, instead of cynically hiking import duty, Govt. would do well if it paves way for either virtual trading of gold or it should launch gold-indexed bonds instead of IIBs. It is well past time to understand that it doesn’t matter how many hurdles or challenges being put up in the gold-game, Indians will bravely and enthusiastically sustain but would not give up till the end.

Bond against Inflation

With an ever increasing import of gold and nose-diving Rupee, government is forced to reckon with the idea of providing a hedge  to investors against  the return eating monster i.e. inflation.  Gold has become  only solace for investors to park their surplus as every other financial instrument has surrendered before the might of stubborn double digit Inflation. Reserve bank of India is now seriously considering to open the window of Inflation Index bonds- a  debt instrument  offering protection against high inflation.

India’s fresh lure of gold is predominantly driven by financial investment needs. Gold imports in India have risen to its peak and resulted in a panicky level of current account deficit and weak rupee resultantly. Apart form making gold imports costlier govt wants to divert the gold buying frenzy towards a befitting investment alternative. Inflation Indexed bond comes as an appropriate option in this context.

Inflation indexed bonds are those overall return on which is adjusted against increasing inflation. Inflation indexed bonds are popular and successful in USA, UK, Australia, Sweden and many other developed countries.  India introduced a derivative of the same i.e. capital indexed bonds earlier in 1997, then again in 2004 but the bond failed to garner attention as only principal amount was indexed against inflation not the coupon rate, consequently the real returns remained unprotected from inflation. RBI is again considering for a new avatar of IIB amid a couple of ifs and buts.

A robust inflation index is the most important pre-requisite for IIBs. India has several inflation measuring indices, ranging from wholesale to retail Inflation. It is still not clear which one would be used for pegging return on IIB . That IIB may disrupt the G-sec market is also a prevailing concern for the central bank. Government securities are the major source of govt  borrowings.  Fixed interest of G-sec will surely make the former i.e. IIBs a preferable investment option over the latter.

The timing of issuing IIBs is also a point to ponder.  Govt or issuer has to shell out  more money during the high inflation period. Considerate thought must also be given to defining tax rate on IIBs returns. Higher taxation on the same will eat into the vitals of returns.  It would be ideally prudent that IIBs are left tax-exempted otherwise it will be of no significance to investors.

IIBs are a welcome concept but the current challenge is to tame the lure of gold to contain higher gold imports. Given the policy bottlenecks of IIBs, it seems doubtful if it can provide equivalent benefit as gold does. Returns on gold is already three times higher than inflation rate with the prospect of spurring further. Gold-indexed bonds , yielding similar returns as this metal does in physical form, could become a better idea in the short run. A cornucopia of IIB and GIB  may do a lot better in the given situation of Indian economy.

A Glittering Risk

Gold must not glisten so much so that it makes Indian economy lose its already fading shine. Rising inclination towards gold investment among Indian populace is a cause of serious trouble for the country. It is one of the potential factors behind ballooning current account deficit, which has widened to an all time high of $22.3 billion, or 5.4% of gross domestic product, in the July-September quarter. Current account deficit (CAD) is measured by the difference between a country's exports of goods, services and transfers and total imports within a time period.

Reserve Bank of India, in its recent Financial Stability Report, showed concern over increasing gold imports. As per its draft report “Gold imports have continued to be high and have accounted for, on an average, over two-thirds of the CAD during the last three years. While India’s share in international trade is less than 2 per cent and that in world GDP is less than 6 per cent in Purchasing Power Parity terms, it accounts for a quarter of world demand for gold.”

The investment sentiment in the economy is at its all time low. High inflation is robbing returns on bank savings while mutual funds and equity are not offering attractive returns either. Gold seems to be the safest option for people to invest their hard-earned money. It is a global phenomenon as people tend to go for gold because it provides them a sure hedge against growing inflation and in an insecure economic environment. Only difference is that their gold trading is paper-based unlike ours. Recently SBI proposed an idea of virtual trading of gold instead that of physical. Gold-linked financial instruments, gold bonds etc must be introduced which yield similar returns as this yellow metal does in physical form. Such paper based gold trading might reduce the problem of physical possession of gold which leads to higher import of gold.

According to the most recent available data from the World Gold Council, India's gold demand during the January-September period of 2012 was 607.6 metric tons, down 24% from a year earlier. It could happen because Govt. had doubled the customs duty on standard gold bars to 4%, and non-standard gold bars was doubled to 10%. But a closer data study reveals that gold imports did fall to 131 tons in the April-June quarter but again rose 9% to 223.1 tons in the July-September quarter. A sharp recovery in Q3 is also likely due to peak festival and wedding season buying. Hence Govt. effort of increasing import duties on gold in the current fiscal year, eventually, bore no fruits.  Yet Finance Minister P. Chidambaram again intends to resort to making gold imports costlier. He must also keep in mind that expensive retail price of gold might lead to smuggling of the same. Govt has also asked gold import agencies such as MMTC and STC to lower the volume and value of gold imports.

Gold loans disbursed by banks and other Non Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) pose a threat to financial stability of banks in India. They lend borrowed cash from banks to people in exchange of gold. RBI says that the bank-debt of these gold-loans companies have increased by 200% over the period of one year. Indian banks will be in trouble if ever NBFCs falter in the wake of volatility in gold price. As per RBI guidelines, these companies can only provide 60% of loan against the value of collateral gold.

Predictions are against any betterment of economic condition in year 2013. This negative sentiment will buttress the trend of gold investment further because real profit through any other savings policies is meager given lower interest rates and inflation. Govt. must understand that bumping up import duties on gold import is not a solution. He would do well if he tries to drift people’s attention away from this yellow metal by offering equally valuable financial products and inflation-indexed policies. Higher gold import is actually not the only problem. Recycling of gold scrap, huge stock of idle gold which is highest in the country and gold-smuggling are few other challenges needing immediate concern. It’s high time that Govt. pursues a viable gold policy. 

The Twin Deficit Trap

Indian economy is in the grip of classic quagmire named twin deficit. Fiscal deficit is already looming large thanks to the acute imbalance of revenue and expenditure. While current account deficit has risen to a precarious level indicating a fragile state of affair at the forex management front. A decadal low growth is making things worse. As stubborn inflation and political fluidity is here to stay, India has become a riskier place for global investors than its emerging market peers.        

A current account deficit occurs when a country’s total import of goods, services and transfers is higher than the total exports of goods, services and transfers. India’s current account deficit (CAD) has peaked to the level of 4.5% of the GDP which denotes that India is importing more and exporting less. This is the highest level of CAD in last 20 years and it is more than 1991, the year when India faced a balance of payments crisis. The skyrocketing CAD is a result of India’s huge foreign trade deficit.  The slowdown in the global economy has taken its toll from India’s exports while imports are rising unabated. Energy import (Crude oil and coal) are the fastest growing imports in last few quarters.

India is also not able to create a favorable investor environment and deters foreign investors to invest in the economy. This is another big drag of forex inflow apart from the skewed export proceeds. This current account deficit puts burden on domestic currency. Rupee has witnessed a fresh onslaught of speculators recently after CAD figure came out to public domain. A current account deficit of about 2% of GDP is sustainable in India which needs foreign funds to propel its growth. But a CAD of 4.5 pc is just a crisis and it is likely to hit rupee further in coming months.

Indian federal budget is perennially in the grip of populist profligacy. The frightening days of high fiscal deficit has returned now.  The Centre's fiscal deficit stood at Rs 3.68 lakh crore in the first seven months of this fiscal, constituting 68.32% of revised target of fiscal deficit for the entire 2012-13. Finance Minister P Chidambaram had earlier revised fiscal deficit target to 5.3% of GDP from the Budget Estimate of 5.1%. Collating GDP figures released today and fiscal deficit figures released last month, fiscal deficit constituted 7.36% of GDP in the first half of 2012-13. Ever major indicator related to fiscal deficit is giving a dismal picture as expenditure on rise and revenue growth has been tapered due to general economic slowdown. Exorbitant subsidies and reckless spending in failed schemes such as MNEREGS is one of the key reasons of fiscal quandary. Government is forced to borrow more from the market to finance its expenditure. Heavy Govt borrowings are crowding out private loans and adding fuel the inflation. The vicious cycle of high fisc def, high govt borrowing, increased money supply, inflation and high interest rates is setting in now.  

Though a minimal amount of fiscal and current account is not bad for the economy but given the present economic environment, it is going to be a deadly deterrent to the prospect of growth.  GDP growth has dipped down to 5.3% in Q2 from 5.5% of the previous quarter. With a below 6pc growth rate twin deficits have become a deadly duo for overall economic management in the nation. A quick correction to the situation seems impossible as India’s unstable political environment is making it further difficult. Indian economy is now venturing in to minefield of uncertainties.  Things will improve only after the political scene becomes clear i.e. after post Loka Sabha elections in 2014.